Insights > Stop playing tricks: The CRO mindset that actually works

Published

Stop playing tricks: The CRO mindset that actually works

Stop playing tricks: The CRO mindset that actually works

Here's the uncomfortable truth about conversion optimisation that most "growth hackers" won't tell you.

The industry is obsessed with manipulation. Dark patterns. Psychology tricks. Squeezing every possible conversion out of your traffic like wringing water from a stone.

And it's all wrong.

The old way: conversion as combat

I've seen it a thousand times. Teams frantically testing:

  • Pop-ups that block content
  • "Only 3 left in stock!" fake urgency
  • Checkout flows designed like mouse mazes
  • Forms asking for your firstborn's National Insurance number

This isn't optimisation. It's warfare against your own users.

The real CRO mindset shift

Stop thinking of conversion optimisation as "tricking" users into converting.

Start seeing it as removing obstacles between users and what they already want.

Here's what changes when you get this right

1. Your tests get smarter

Instead of asking "How can we get more people to click?" You ask: "What's stopping people who want to click?"

Real example: We had a client with a 47% basket abandonment rate. The "growth hack" crowd suggested countdown timers and scarcity messaging.

We asked users what was wrong. Turns out, the delivery calculator was hidden at checkout. People wanted to see total costs upfront.

One simple fix. 28% improvement. No manipulation required.

2. You create actual value

When you adopt this service mindset, your tests focus on solving user problems rather than squeezing out conversions.

  • Is your checkout flow confusing? Fix it.
  • Are your pricing options unclear? Clarify them.
  • Do people struggle to find what they need? Improve navigation.

"But that's just good UX!"

Exactly. That's what conversion optimisation should be.

3. Your results last longer

Manipulation wears off. Users get wise to fake urgency. They resent being tricked.

But solving real problems? That builds trust. And trust leads to long-term relationships, repeat customers, and word-of-mouth.

Paradoxically, your conversion rates improve even more when you stop trying so hard to convert.

The practical framework

  1. Identify real obstacles
    • Use analytics to find drop-off points
    • Watch user recordings (without sound effects)
    • Ask actual customers what's confusing
  2. Test solutions, not tricks
    • Simplify, don't complicate
    • Clarify, don't obscure
    • Help, don't hustle
  3. Measure like you mean it
    • Track satisfaction, not just conversion
    • Monitor long-term retention
    • Celebrate reduced support tickets

The bottom line

Great CRO isn't about manipulation—it's about making the path to value clearer and easier.

When was the last time you felt good about being "growth hacked"? Never.

But when was the last time you appreciated a smooth, thoughtful user experience? Probably today.

Your users aren't opponents to defeat. They're customers trying to solve problems. Help them do that better.

The conversion rates will take care of themselves.

Ready to stop playing conversion games and start solving real problems? Let's talk about what's actually broken on your website.